Monday, 15 July 2013

Revelation 9: The Trumpet Call to Repentance

Introduction

“O God (if there is God), save my soul (if there is soul) from sin (if there is sin).”[1] This is the general attitude of the modern human being. The consciousness of sin is gradually fading away. Human being is trying to play God through various scientific experiments. Ethical, environmental and human considerations are not taken into consideration when economic policies of globalization and development are planned and executed. Farmers are committing suicide. Children are dying of malnutrition. The PDS (Public Distribution System) is in shambles as millions of tonnes of foodgrain is rotting in government’s FCI godowns. India seems to be in the clutches of the evil one.
Communalism is on the rise; fundamentalist forces are making the life of poor Christians unlivable in many places in India. The attitude towards women is still very negative; they are looked at as mere sex objects. Prostitution, child labour, domestic violence, substance abuse, terrorism, naxalism, exploitation of the weak and the marginalized; the list of human sinfulness is endless.
It seems that the present situation in India is not much different from the situation prevalent in Asia Minor when The Revelation was written by John. In the midst of this sinful situation, the trumpet call from the angels is a wakeup call to arise from our slumber.
The message of the Trumpets is loud and clear: repent and return to God (the almighty παντακράτωρ, the creator and the sovereign God of the universe) and his Son Jesus Christ (the redeemer, the slaughtered lamb standing), so that “every creature in heaven and on earth and under the earth and in the sea may sing” their praises (Rev 5:13). Through the symbolism of Trumpets, John is pleading with the Christians: “Can’t you see what is happening. Repent! Change your way of looking at things! Wake up before it is too late.”[2]

 

My way of proceeding

Reality is multifaceted and when this reality is expressed in symbolic language, it becomes even more complex and intricate. The same is true about the Revelation. As Harrington says, “The Apocalypse [Revelation] has the freedom of great art” and it is “a work of great imaginative power and of deep religious feeling.”[3] So, we cannot look at it in one single perspective. Various authors approach the Revelation from varying points of view. This causes a difficulty for a beginner like me to do the exegetical analysis of this great work of art. That is why I would like to approach this Herculean task of exegesis of Revelation 9 with complete humility.
 I know fully well that however much I try I will not be able to deal the topic comprehensively and do full justice to the rich symbolism this text and the whole book offers. Nevertheless, I will give my best. I will approach the topic by using the following methodology: (1) The delimitation of the text; (2) Examining the original text for textual criticism, (3) Exploring the Sitz im leben (4) Exploring the literary context of the text (5) Exegesis of the Text and (6) Theological implications and Contextual reflections for today.

1.     The Delimitation of the text

The text under consideration includes fifth and sixth trumpet judgment which comes immediately after the announcement of the three woes by an eagle in Rev 8:13 and before the prophetic vision of the mighty angel and the scroll. The question of delimitation is whether we can consider this as a single unit. Let us first see analysis of the structure of the seven trumpets (8:2–11:19) given by Robert Mounce:
A.  Preparation (8:2–5)
B.  First Four Trumpets (8:6–12)
C.  Eagles’ Warning (8:13)
D.  Fifth Trumpet (First Woe): Demonic Locusts (9:1–12)
E.   Sixth Trumpet (Second Woe): Fiendish Cavalry (9:13–21)
     Interlude: Visions of the Prophetic Role (10:1–11:14)
            1. The Mighty Angel and the Little Scroll (10:1–11)
            2. Measuring the Temple (11:1–2)
            3. The Two Witnesses (11:3–14)
F.  Seventh Trumpet (11:15–19)[4]
            As seen above, these are two pericopes put together. However, since the accounts of two trumpets display a parallel structure[5], it is fitting to put them together as delimitation.

2.     Textual Criticism

After going through the original text, I found that a minor textual critical problem arises in Rev 9:13 which reads “καὶ ὁ ἕκτος ἄγγελος ἐσάλπισεν, καὶ ἤκουσα φωνὴν μίαν ἐκ τῶν [τέσσαρων] κεράτων τοῦ θυσιαστηρίου τοῦ χρυσοῦ τοῦ ἐνώπιον τοῦ θεοῦ.” The problem is concerning the bracketed word “τέσσαρων” which is present in several manuscripts. However, scholars have resolved the issue by putting the word in the bracket because the strong external evidence (being absent in older manuscripts like ˡﬡ) suggests that it is an addition (intentional error) made by later scribes to mention the number of horns of the altar.

3.     Sitz im leben (Socio-Cultural Context)

Most scholars agree that the Revelation was written in Asia Minor where Christians were undergoing persecution under the emperor Domitian who had declared himself κύριος. Harrigton expresses this situation of the early Christians as follows: “Emperor–worship demanded that sacrifice be offered (or incense burned) before an image of Caesar, with the declaration: Kyrios Kaisar—‘Caesar is Lord’, that is, divine—sheer blasphemy in Christian eyes. For Christians Jesus Christ was Kyrios, and they must ‘hold fast his name’ (Rev 2:13), reserving that title for him alone.”[6]
In that context, The Revelation can be seen as “the confrontation between the followers of Jesus and the Roman Empire.”[7] Fallon expresses the concern of the author and his purpose of writing the book as follows: “He [John] is concerned with what is happening in Asia Minor, and he is concerned to challenge those Christians who are giving in to the seductive temptation to compromise with the Roman system and enjoy its apparent benefits, and to support those who are trying to be faithful to the way of life they learned from Jesus, even though they are being disadvantaged and even persecuted because of it.”[8]
Keeping these things in mind, I think, ‘Renouncing idolatry and wickedness and being a true witness (μάρτυς) to Jesus Christ in the midst of persecution’ is the main message of John to his readers. Fallon puts it aptly, “John is calling the Christians to look squarely at the rotten fruit of those who arrogantly ignore God and to repent while there is still time.”[9] That is what the trumpet call is all about. It is a warning as well as encouragement to the struggling churches in Asia Minor.

4.     Literary Context of the Text

It is not easy to give the literary context of this text because as I said earlier there is not one way of looking at the text. Adela Collins looks at “what is to come” (1:19) as cycles of seven visions following one after the other (seals, trumpets, unnumbered visions×2, bowls).[10] Harrington divides the book in three parts; Part I: Church and Israel (4–11), Part II: The Church and pagan Rome (12:1–20:15) and Part III: The New Jerusalem (21:1–22:5).[11]
It is interesting to see how Fr. Joyce Kaithakottil puts the whole book pictorially: God the Almighty (1:8) and the Lamb, Risen Christ (5:6) seek the conversion of the Churches (2–3) so that the Church becomes a faithful witness (11:1–13). In this process of witnessing, there is identification with Christ (11:8) and confrontation with the world (11:7). This faithful witness through cross and martyrdom brings about the conversion of the world and in turn the New Heaven and New Earth (21:1). God almighty sees all this and vindicates the faithful through resurrection. He judges and punishes the wicked by throwing them in the lake of fire.
In this schema, we see Seals, Trumpets and Bowls as judgments coming from God, calling people to conversion. Harrington sees seals and trumpets coming under Part I which deals with Church and Israel, the people of God. Hence the judgments are only partial and can be seen as a clear call to conversion. However, Adela Collins gives the dramatic progression taking place with varying points of views: messages (Christian communities) to seals (all humanity) to trumpets (cosmic point of view) with her focus on the vision of the end with escalating scale of judgment (1/4th humanity is destined to die in the 4th seal to 1/3rd in the sixth trumpet). [12] Thus, the trumpets are midway in the crescendo of divine judgment. Through partial judgment, he merciful God calls his people back to his loving embrace.

5.     Exegesis

Before giving the exegesis of the given text (Rev 9:1–21), first I will give a short description about Trumpets in the Bible; then I will explain the preparation (8:2), first four trumpets (8:6–12), and Eagle’s warning (8:13) briefly and then move towards the exegesis.

Trumpet (σάλπινξ)

The Revelation is full of symbolism. Trumpet is one such powerful symbol deeply rooted in Semitic culture and literature. In the OT the trumpet was used extensively for a variety of purposes.[13] It is interesting to know that in Hebrew Bible, the word ‘trumpet’ occurs 93 times, in the Deutero–canonical book 18 times and in the New Testament 20 times, out of which 15 occurrences are in the Revelation.
The judgment motif is very strong in the later literature, especially in the Intertestamental literature and in the New Testament (Apoc. Zeph. 9–12; Mt 24:31; 1 Cor 15:52; 1 Thes 4:16). Collins mentions, “the form of the cycle of trumpets was inspired by the image of the trumpet blast on the Day of the Lord (see Joel 2:1 and Is 27:13).[14]
In the Revelation, the significance of the trumpet is described by Jones in the following points: (i) Imagery is based on what is heard, “a loud voice like a trumpet” (Rev 1:10). (ii) Devastation of the earth with its plague and its cosmic associations (Rev 8:6–9:13). (iii) The call to penitence (Rev 9:20). (iv) The announcement of the Day of the Lord (Rev 14). (v) The holiness of the divine presence (Rev 4:1, cf. Ex 19:16). (vi) Interplay of heavenly and earthly liturgies (Rev 8:1ff).[15] Voice of the trumpet conveys prophetic authority, too (Ezek 2:2; 3:12; 11:1; 14:22). So, I would like to focus the trumpets as the prophetic call to repentance in the face of the impending judgment.

Preparation (8:2)

It is very interesting to see the gradual unraveling taking place in the Revelation. The seventh seal unfolds seven trumpets (8:1–5) and the seventh trumpet unfolds seven bowls (11:15–19). Here we have dramatic change of scene taking place. Ford expresses it beautifully, “The chapter begins with an ominous silence. This has an important dramatic effect as well as theological relevance, by providing a sharp contrast to the loud and ceaseless songs of praise sung in ch. 7 by the angels, elders, and living creatures in heaven. The silent pause is calculated to fill the reader with expectation.”[16]
The author prepares the scene for the trumpeting angels in 8:2 where seven angels who stand before God are given seven trumpets. According to Harrington, “These are the ‘angels of the presence’ (cf. Is 63:9—‘the angel of the presence’), the seven ‘archangels’ (cf. 1 Enoch 20: 1–8) of Jewish tradition who serve God, namely, Michael, Gabriel, Raphael, Uriel, Raguel, Sariel and Remiel.[17] The term ‘seven angels’ έττα α҆γγέλους appears nine times in the Revelation, twice in the section of Trumpets and seven times in the section of Bowls. Aune gives us parallels between seven trumpets and seven bowls (15:1–16:21).[18] We must keep in mind that all the three judgments (Seals, Trumpets and Bowls) are issued from the Divine Throne room where the Almighty and his Lamb are being worshipped (5:13).

First four trumpets (8:6–12)

The cycle of Trumpets begins. Harrington connects the prayers of martyrs with it very insightfully, “The martyrs had prayed: ‘… how long before you will judge and avenge our blood on those who dwell upon the earth?’ (6:10); now their prayer, which had gone up to God (8:4), returns to the earth in wrath.”[19] It is not difficult to see the connection between the trumpet plagues with plagues in Egypt (Ex 7–12). Collins rightly points out, “An analogy is seen between their [Christians in Asia Minor] ill treatment by the Romans and the slavery experienced by the children of Israel in Egypt. Just as God delivered his people in the past, so will he again.”[20] Because of these plagues, 1/3rd of earth, sea, fresh waters and heavenly bodies get affected. This imperfect number (1/3) symbolizes partial judgment.

Eagles’ warning (8:13)

After this comes a surprise entry of an eagle. As Fallon puts it, “John injects special dramatic tension into the scene, preparing us for the terrible final three announcements.”[21]
Aune describes the development so far as follows: “The plagues unleashed by the seven trumpets consist of a group of four that have a homogeneous character and are described very succinctly (8:7–12). The last three trumpets also have a homogeneous framework in that they presumably consist of a series of three woes (8:13–9:21; 11:14–18).”
Now I come to the exegesis of the text proper. It is impossible to give the detailed exegesis. Therefore, I will mention only major exegetical points leaving aside intricate exegetical details which were given during the class presentation. I will briefly mention fifth and sixth trumpet, and then focus on the call to repentance (9:20–21).

Fifth Trumpet (9:1–12)

The fifth trumpet plague deals with the horde of demonic locusts. This has close parallel with the eighth plague in Egypt (Ex 10:1–20) and Joel 2:4–11. As Collins puts it, “In the book of Exodus, a swarm of locusts was God’s instrument in chastising the enemies of God’s people. In Joel 2, a plague of locusts is about to be used by the Lord to punish the Lord’s own people.[22]The description of demonic locusts finds close parallel with Joel 2:4–11.
Fallen star from heaven was given the key to the shaft of the bottomless pit (9:1):
(a) Fallen star (ἀστέρα πεπτωκότα): In early Jewish literature, stars represent angelic beings (Judg 5:20; Job 38:7; Dan 8:10), demons (1 Enoch 86:3; 88:1; 90:24; T. Sol. 20.14–17; Jude 13), or even Satan (1 Enoch 86:1; Apoc. El. 4:11; Luke 10:18; Rev 12:9. The falling star in Sib. Or. 5.155–61 has some parallels with Rev 9:1–2.[23] Many scholars hold that position. However, in 20:1–3, we see a similar occurrence where an angel comes down from heaven and binds and throws Satan into the pit. So, the identity of the fallen angel remains unknown to us. However, in the scheme of Revelation, we would have to rule out Satan.
 (b) The key (κλείς):  We have four references to the key in the Revelation (1:18; 3:7; 9:1; 20:1). This key is a sign of authority over death and Hades and only God and his lamb possess it, showing their supremacy.
(c) The bottomless pit (ἄβυσσος): The term ἄβυσσος occurs seven times in Revelation (9:1, 2, 11; 11:7; 17:8; 20:1, 3). In the three–level cosmology of Revelation, it is the place where demons are imprisoned (Luke 8:31; 1 Enoch 18–21). In Revelation the beast ascends from the abyss (11:7; 17:8), and it is also the abode of Satan (20:1–3), of the angel of the abyss, Abaddon or Apollyon (9:11), and of demons (9:1–10).[24]
Thus, in the first verse of the chapter, a great drama takes place after the fifth angel blows his trumpet. Collins attributes the resurgence of evil in the world to this phenomenon of the release of the evil spirits from their confinement.[25] Then, John goes on to give a very graphic description of the swarm of demonic locusts. This horde of demonic locusts is deadly because of their quantity and harmfulness (the authority of scorpions, 9:3).
The Demonic Locusts (9:7–10): Some scholars consider this plague either as actual attack of locusts (ακρίδες) or symbolically referring to the army of Parthians (Iranians). Both interpretations are feasible if we carefully examine the description of Demonic Locusts. I will not go into the details, but highlight a few areas to make my point.
Vincent consistently considers this plague to actual locusts. He writes, “The likeness of a locust to a horse, especially to a horse equipped with armor, is so striking that the insect is named in German Heupferd Hay-horse, and in Italian cavaletta little horse.”[26]He focuses on the word “ὡς” repeatedly used and gives various examples to show how real locusts are capable of creating great catastrophe.[27] No wonder, a vast enemy army is compared in number to locusts (Judg 6:5; 7:12; Jer 46:23; 51:14; Joel 1–2; Amos 4:9).
            On the other hand, Ford and Aune compare these demonic locusts to the Parthians who wore long hair (like women),[28] who had heavily armored cavalry (both horse and rider)[29] and who shot poisoned arrows over their shoulders as they retreated (like scorpion’s sting).[30]
The king of the demonic locusts (9:11): 9/11 brings to our mind destruction and right enough the king of this infernal army is named Abaddon (אֲבַדּוֹ֝): destruction personified; which is a Hebrew term for the kingdom of the dead (Prov 15:11; Job 26:6; 28:22; 31:12; Ps 88:12).[31] In Greek, he is called Appolyon (Απολλύων): Greek archer god Apollo who poisoned his victims and who had the grasshopper or locust as one of the emblems.[32]
Some other exegetically important points need to be clarified. They are as follows:
Divine protection for the sealed (9:4):  The seal of God (σφραγῖς τοῦ θεοῦ) refers us back to 7:2–8 and makes it explicit that the purpose of sealing is that of protection. According to Aune, “The motif of protection is central in the sealing episode in Ezek 9:3–8, as it is in Pss. Sol. 15:4–9, a passage that expands on Ezek 9 and contrasts the mark of God with the mark of destruction.”[33] Jn 6:27 speaks about God putting his seal on Jesus Christ and St. Paul speaks about God putting the seal of the Holy Spirit on us (2 Cor 1:22; Eph 1:13; Eph 4:30). This shows God’s concern for the faithful in the midst of fearful events.  
Symbolism of five months (9:5): The locusts do not kill men, but torment them for five months (μήνας πέντε). Ford gives three explanations referring the plague as: (i) the ancients’ fear of locust invasions, which occurred during the last five months of the Jewish year, (ii) partial punishment because five months is less than half the total twelve months of the year, and (iii) the five months during which the troops of Gessius Florus cast terror over Palestine. [34] For me, the most plausible explanation is that through this partial and moderated punishment God calls people to repent and return to him. God is in control of the history. The faithful are protected, but wicked are tortured so that they seek death (9:6).
Use of the Divine passive (9:1–5): While it seems the hell is being let loose, the faithful need not be afraid because God is in complete control. In vv 3–5, a series of statements is made using passive verbs (v 3, ἐδόθη, “was given”; v 4, ἐρρέθη, “were instructed”; v 5, ἐδόθη, “was given”).[35] In v 1, too, we find ἐδόθη. Besides, God shows his ecological consciousness by giving command not to damage any vegetation (9:4). All these things point out that these trumpet plagues are sent by good God with a specific purpose.

Sixth Trumpet (9:13–19)

A voice from the horns of the golden altar before God (9:13): According to Ford, “This is the heavenly altar, a counterpart of the earthly one; Exod 27:1–2, 30:1–2.”[36] This is the altar under which the souls of the righteous cried out (6:9). The horn represents strength; the horns of the altar represent the strength and splendour of God; so the voice coming out from it carries the power of God to establish justice in the world on behalf of the righteous.
The four angels bound at the great river Euphrates (9:14): The Euphrates is the longest river in western Asia: seventeen hundred miles long. According to Vincent, “The melting of the mountain snows causes an annual flood, beginning in March and increasing until May. These floods became an emblem of the judgments inflicted by God upon Israel by means of Babylon and Assyria…To the prophets the Euphrates was the symbol of all that was disastrous in the divine judgments. (Is 8: 5–8; Jer 17:13).”[37]This may also refer to the marauding Parthians coming beyond Euphrates to invade Palestine.
Prepared to kill a third of humankind with a huge cavalry (9:15–16): Unlike the fifth trumpet plague, here 1/3 of humankind (partial) is destined to be killed according to the pre-determined Divine plan (9:15).  Cavalry of two hundred million riders (9:16) appears to be a demonic rather than a human army. Huge armies of destroying angels are mentioned in Babylonian Talmud.[38] In 1 Enoch 56:5–6, there is a reference that the angels explicitly functioned to incite the kings of the east to gather their armies and attack Israel.[39]This might give us the connection between four angels and the demonic cavalry. “Who were prepared (οἱ ἡτοιμασμένοι) and “were released” (ἐλύθησαν) are divine passive.
Vision of the Demonic Cavalry (9:17–19): Aune finds similarity between the creature mentioned in the Revelation with Chimaera in Greko–Roman mythology.
A combination of three creatures, with the body of a horse, the head of a lion, and the tail of snake heads. The closest approximation to such a creature in antiquity is probably the Chimaera slain by the hero Bellerophon with the aid of Pegasus as described in Greek and Roman mythology. The Chimaera is consistently described as having the head of a lion, the tail of a dragon or serpent, and the body of a goat and belching fire (Iliad 6.181–82; Hesiod Theog. 319–24; Euripides Ion 203–4; Electra 474–75; Apollodorus 2.3.1.[40]

We find a fire–breathing sea–monster named Leviathan in Job 41:19–21. Here plagues of fire and smoke and sulfur came out of these creatures’ mouths. The word “Plagues” (πληγῶν) occurs 15 times in the Revelation and this is the first occurrence. We have Gen 19:24 account of the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah by fire and brimstone as a prototype of judgment. Similarly fire and sulfur are frequently mentioned in the Revelation as vehicles of divine judgment (9:17–18; 14:10; 19:20; 20:10; 21:8).[41]
Parallel with the Egyptian plagues: Collins sees the tenth plague as the closest parallel, in which all of the first–born in Egypt were slain, including human beings (Exodus 11–12). Here, a third of humanity is slain.[42] Ford has an interesting theory where he calls it the reversal of the red sea drowning of the horses and riders.[43] The main point to keep in mind is that God who heard the cry ( (צעקof Israelites in Egypt and liberated them is the same God active in liberating his people suffering under the imperial rule.

Call to Repentance (9:20–21)

Now we come to the purpose of the trumpet plagues, which is the call to penitence:
They did not repent (ουδέ μετενόησαν): Unfortunately just as Pharaoh and Egyptians responded to the plagues by being hard–hearted, humanity responds to the trumpet judgments. They do not repent of their idolatry and wickedness.
ἵνα μὴ προσκυνήσουσιν τὰ δαιμόνια καὶ τὰ εἴδωλα: Idolatry quickly brings to our mind the Emperor worship. Seeing from the perspective of the strict Judeo-Christian monotheistic faith, it is completely unacceptable. It is breaking the very first commandment of Decalogue (Ex 20:2–6). Aune explains this beautifully, “The ἵνα clause here functions as a result clause; i.e., they did not repent with the result that they might no longer worship idols.”[44] Besides ‘καὶ’ is an explanatory καὶ, which means, demons, i.e. idols. Ps 115:4–7 speak about the powerlessness of idols.
Covenantal infidelity and social injustice were the two evils prophets in OT denounced vehemently. Actually both are not divorced from one another, but intimately connected. According to Fallon, “Failure to worship the true God leads to a breakdown of just human relationships. This is stated by John (9:21) in terms of the fifth to the tenth commandments (Ex 20:13–17).”[45] Three vice-lists are given in the Revelation (9:21; 21:8; 22:15), which are quite similar and all of them denounce idolatry and wickedness. Thus we find the message of this chapter very clearly towards the end: “repent or perish.”

6.     Theological Implications and Contextual Reflections

The situation of John’s church in Asia Minor is not much different from the situation of India. In this context, I draw out a few theological and contextual reflections as follows:
i) The rule of Abaddon/Appolyon in today’s world: Abaddon or Applyon is the personified destruction. Today, US-sponsored neo-imperialistic globalizing propaganda is turning out to be Abaddon for the third-world countries like India. The result of it is seen in all spheres of life. Ethical and ecological degradation, spiritual bankruptcy, loss of bio–diversity, escalating poverty and inequality, wars, famines, etc. are only a few expressions of this destructive force. Demonic powers are working through human agency. Humanbeing has become a strong ally of the angel of the bottomless pit. That is why, humanity is sinking into deep abyss, losing itself in the false prosperity theology, materialism and consumerism.
ii) Modern day Idolatry and new list of vices: “Na baap, no bhaiyya, sabse bada rupayya” (Not father, not brother, the greatest is money) that is the slogan of today. Mammon has assumed primacy in the world. Jesus tells us, “You cannot serve two masters” (Mt 6:24). But, idolatry of “I” is reaching greater heights. The place of one true God is taken over by demi-gods, competing for our allegiance. The Revelation gives us three lists of sins. In the modern world, all ethical norms are thrown to the wind and the culture of death is promoted through abortion, euthanasia, same-sex marriage, genetic modifications, abuse of technology, etc.
c) Know God, Know Salvation: In the midst of this world, where apparently evil force is having its sway, we are invited to know the true nature of God, i.e. God is love. He loves passionately and he desires all to come to him and be saved. The so-called “wrath” is also expression of his love, calling all to repentance. Once we know the all-powerful, all-loving, merciful and just God, then we will not lose heart in the face of the evil. We will be reflectors of God’s light in the world. We will go through continual process of repentance. We will struggle with the evil forces within and without and persevere in faith. Because we know that in God and in the slaughtered and standing lamb, our salvation lies.
d) Repent and Return: Even if we have been far away from God, we are not doomed. Through trumpet warnings, God gives us chances to come back. Trumpet judgments are only partial. It is never too late. Surrendering to God and giving witness to him will ascertain eternal life for us.

Conclusion

The book of Revelation is a highly dynamic book. It is a revolutionary and subversive piece of work. The allusion to Egyptian plagues makes this book a second Exodus. Just as Exodus, God’s definitive intervention in the history formed the people of God, Israel. In a similar way, new Israel, the kingdom of God is formed by Gods’ continual intervention in the history through the faithful witness of the Church. It is not easy. Church also falters and fails and that is why the trumpet call keeps us on our toes and calls us to continuous conversion of heart so that God and his lamb may be glorified by all (5:13), Amen.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Aune, D. E. Revelation 6-16. The Word Biblical Commentary, Vol. 52B. Dallas: Word Books, 2002
Collins, Adela Yarbo. The Apocalypse. Collegeville: The Liturgical Press, 1990.
Fallon, Michael. The Apocalypse: A Call to Embrace the Love that is Stronger than Death. Bangalore: Asian Trading Corporation, 2005.
Ford, J. M.  Revelation. The Anchor Yule Bible Commentary. London: Yale University Press, 2008.
Harrington, Wilfrid J. The Apocalypse of St. John. London: Geoffrey Chapman, 1969.
Jones, Ivor H. “Musical Instruments,” The Anchor Bible Dictionary, Vol. 4. New York: Doubleday: 1992; 934-939.
Mounce, Robert. The Book of Revelations Revised. The New International Commentary on the New Testament (NICNT). Michigan: Grand Rapids, 1977.
Vincent, Marvin R. The Writings of John. Word Studies in the New Testament, Vol. II Massachusetts: Henrickson, 1980.
Table of Contents







[1] A popular saying modified: ‘from sin (if there is sin)’ is my personal addition.
[2] Michael Fallon, The Apocalypse: A Call to Embrace the Love that is Stronger than Death (Bangalore: Asian Trading Corporation, 2005), 61.
[3] Wilfrid J. Harrington, The Apocalypse of St. John (London: Geoffrey Chapman, 1969), 26.
[4] Robert Mounce, The Book of Revelations Revised (NICNT; Michigan: Grand Rapids, 1977), 34.
[5] See David E. Aune, Revelation 6-16 (WBC 52B; Dallas: Word Books, 2002), 497.
[6] Harington, Apocalypse of St. John, 23.
[7] Adela Yarbo Collins, The Apocalypse (Collegeville: The Liturgical Press, 1990), xi.
[8] Fallon, Apocalypse, 11.
[9] Fallon, Apocalypse, 66.
[10] Collins, Apocalypse, xii-xiii.
[11] Harrington, Apocalypse of St. John, 26-28.
[12] Collins, Apocalypse, 56.
[13] For detailed discussion on the use of trumpets in OT and intertestamental period, see Ivor H. Jones, “Musical Instruments,” The Anchor Bible Dictionary, Vol. 4 (New York: Doubleday: 1992; 934-939), 939.
[14] Collins, 57-58.
[15] Jones, “Musical Instruments”, 939.
[16] J. Massyngberde Ford, Revelation (ABC; London: Yale University Press, 2008), 134
[17] Harrington, Apocalypse of St. John,134.
[18] See Aune, Revelation 6-16,498.
[19] Harrington, Apocalypse of St. John, 135.
[20] Collins, Apocalypse, 58.
[21] Fallon, Apocalypse, 63.
[22] Collins, Apocalypse, 60-61.
[23]Aune, Revelation 6–16, 525.
[24]Aune, Revelation 6–16, 526.
[25] Collins, Apocalypse, 60.
[26] Marvin R. Vincent, The Writings of John (Word Studies in the NT, II Massachusetts: Henrickson, 1980), 508.
[27] For detailed discussion, see Vincent, Writings of John, 508-09.
[28] Ford, Revelation, 151.
[29]Aune, Revelation, 533.
[30] Ford, Revelation, 151.
[31] Aune, Revelation 6–16, 534.
[32] Ford, Revelation, 152.
[33] Aune, Revelation 6–16, 530.
[34] Ford, Revelation, 149.
[35] Aune, Revelation 6–16, 527.
[36] Ford, Revelation, 153.
[37] Vincent, Writings of St. John, 509.
[38] Aune, Revelation 6–16, 538.
[39] Aune, Revelation 6–16, 538.
[40] Aune, Revelation 6–16, 539.
[41] Aune, Revelation 6–16, 541.
[42] Collins, Apocalypse, 63.
[43] Ford, Revelation, 155.
[44]Aune, Revelation 6–16, 542.
[45] Fallon, Apocalypse, 67.

No comments:

Post a Comment